Welcome to Islay Whisky Reviews. Here you will find whisky reviews, retrospective posts on trips to Islay, information on buying Islay whisky, and general musings on this beautiful island and its storied history from an American admirer.

Recent Posts

Bruichladdich Octomore 14.2
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Bruichladdich Octomore 14.2

Dubbed the Impossible Equation, the Octomore series from Bruichladdich challenges everything we think we know about whisky. The Octomore 14.2 is super heavily peated, matured only 5 years, 57.7% ABV, and matured in sherry and wine casks. Can all these ideas come together to deliver a great dram?

Read More
Scotch Malt Whisky Society The Finesse of a Fragrant Furnace
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Scotch Malt Whisky Society The Finesse of a Fragrant Furnace

Could this be our last Feis Ile 2023 review of the year? If it is, we are ending with a Scotch Malt Whisky Society offering, The Finesse of a Fragrant Furnace. Made in partnership with Bowmore, this whisky was the oldest of all the whiskies released for Feis Ile 2023 by the SMWS.

Read More
Ardbeg Day Single Cask No. 2787
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Ardbeg Day Single Cask No. 2787

An Ardbeg single cask whisky is not something you get the chance to try every day, so we made sure to appreciate the Ardbeg Day Single Cask No. 2787. With any single cask whisky, you are bound to get something special and unique, but is it worth the price tag that comes with all that allure?

Read More
Douglas Laing’s Big Peat The Smokehouse Edition Feis Ile 2023
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Douglas Laing’s Big Peat The Smokehouse Edition Feis Ile 2023

The Big Peat The Smokehouse Edition Feis Ile 2023 release is the first Big Peat whisky to be aged “predominantly” in red wine casks. In this post, we think about what exactly predominantly means in this case, and how this whisky compares to an old favorite also matured in red wine casks.

Read More
Mac-Talla Pedro Ximenez Fèis Ìle 2023 Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Mac-Talla Pedro Ximenez Fèis Ìle 2023 Review

The Mac-Talla Pedro Ximenez Feis Ile 2023 release is the first Feis release put out by Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers. A nice cask selection, but how does this Pedro Ximenez-matured whisky compare to other Pedro Ximenez-matured whiskies we have reviewed?

Read More
Lagavulin Fèis Ìle 2023 14-Year-Old Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Lagavulin Fèis Ìle 2023 14-Year-Old Review

We have another Feis Ile 2023 bottling from this year’s festival, the Lagavulin Feis Ile 2023 14-Year-Old. The first ever Lagavulin finished in armagnac offers the chance to try something new, but is it worth the high price tag?

Read More
Bunnahabhain Fèis Ìle 2023: Canasta Cask Matured Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Bunnahabhain Fèis Ìle 2023: Canasta Cask Matured Review

This review of the Bunnahabhain Canasta Cask Matured offering completes our reviews of all three Bunnahabhain Feis Ile releases from 2023. You will have to read more to find out where it ranks against the other releases from this year.

Read More
Keeping Score
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Keeping Score

This post covers our scoring system for how we will rate whiskies moving forward, and how we applied this scoring system to the whiskies we have already covered.

Read More
Kilchoman 2020 Fino Sherry Matured Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Kilchoman 2020 Fino Sherry Matured Review

We don’t have the Kilchoman 2023 Fino Sherry release to review, but we are hoping the 2020 Fino Sherry release will offer a glimpse of what Kilchoman came up with for this year.

Read More
Ardbeg Hypernova Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Ardbeg Hypernova Review

How smoky is the smokiest Ardbeg ever? We explore the depths of the ppm universe in this latest post.

Read More
Bruichladdich Rock’ndaal 01.2 Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Bruichladdich Rock’ndaal 01.2 Review

While we wait for the Rock’ndaal 02.2 from Feis Ile 2023, we are excited to look back at the 2022 Rock’ndaal 01.2 release and hopefully get a preview of what is to come.

Read More
Ardbeg BizarreBQ Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Ardbeg BizarreBQ Review

We are firing up the grill and throwing on Ardbeg’s BizarreBQ limited release. We like most of the flavors described that went into this whisky, but how does BBQ fit into the mix?

Read More
Bunnahabhain Fèis Ìle 2023: 17-Year-Old Mòine Triple Cask Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Bunnahabhain Fèis Ìle 2023: 17-Year-Old Mòine Triple Cask Review

Only 1,740 Bunnahabhain Fèis Ìle 2023: 17-Year-Old Mòine Triple Cask bottles were made available, but we were able to get our hands on one. It’s got a little bourbon, rum, and Oloroso sherry cask whisky in it, so we wanted to see if all these flavors can come together nicely.

Read More
Kilchoman Loch Gorm 2023 Review
Daniel Helfand Daniel Helfand

Kilchoman Loch Gorm 2023 Review

Like previous releases of it, the Kilchoman Loch Gorm is aged exclusively in Oloroso sherry casks. 22 casks, all of which are at least eight-years matured, have been blended together for the 2023 release.

Read More